A Certain Scientific Railgun Vol. 08 Manga Review (Time for the B-Team to Shine!)

とある科学の超電磁砲(レールガン)/Toaru Kagaku no Railgun

A Certain Scientific Railgun Vol. 08 (manga review) 

–> BUY FROM AMAZON!

SPOILER Summary/Synopsis:  

Things with this volume start with Mikoto’s mom coming by for a visit because of the Daihasei Festival. Mitsuko substitutes for the recovering Kuroko for the Balloon Hunting event. Misaka-10032 is mistaken for the missing Mikoto, who’s very late in arriving, so Misaka Imouto does the event in her place, showing off some of the skills learned during the Level 6 Shift project, but losing in the end. Afterward, Mikoto meets up with her, having watched the event, and praises her. When she leaves to have lunch with her mom, Misaka Imouto collapses due to an injury and is found by Misaki. While Mikoto is buying drinks, Touma shows up, then Misaki arrives and introduces herself to Touma with flair.

Saten decides to hunt for the rumored Shadow Metal and Uiharu decides to help remotely. Going to the stadium where a big event was held between esper schools, Saten is searching when she’s captured by men in protective suits. When Kuroko and Mikoto learn of this, Kuroko teleports them to the location, where Mikoto attacks Saten’s attackers, only to discover they were a cleaning crew designed to keep esper DNA from being salvaged. Meanwhile, Uiharu discovers the website where Saten learned about Shadow Metal and discovers things about a supposed DNA computer that can give birth to esper abilities.

The following day, Mikoto learns that Misaka Imouto hadn’t returned a borrowed P.E. suit and decides to investigate, where she discovers Misaka Imouto was hurt, but the paramedics that took her to the hospital lied about which one they took her too, eventually causing Mikoto to realize Misaki must be involved. Misaki captures Kuroko, Saten, and Uiharu and changes their memories so that later when Mikoto encounters them, they don’t know her other than by reputation. The head mistress of Mikoto’s school puts Mikoto under the supervision of Misaki’s faction as she too is under Misaki’s control. Mikoto quickly discovers what Misaki did to her friends and is determined to lose her guardians.

During the next festival event, Mikoto is teamed up with Mitsuko, who reveals she knew Misaka Imouto wasn’t Mikoto but let it slide, assuming it was Mikoto’s sister. Mikoto confides in her about what is happening and Mitsuko agrees to help but cautions Mikoto not to believe her right away if she comes back with info on Misaka Imotou since Misaki could change her memories. After they win the event, Mitsuko sets out to investigate and is targeted by Baba-kun, who’d orchestrated Misaka Imouto’s defeat the day before. Mitsuko finds Misaka Imouto’s kitten when Baba finds her and reveals he knows something about Misaka Imouto. However, he wants whatever info Mitsuko has and defeats her with robot dogs he controls when she tries to save the kitten.

Wannai and Awatsuki arrive on scene with Saten. They have Saten carry the unconscious and battered Mitsuko away as they battle Baba and his robot dogs. They do better than expected, so he is forced to use a mosquito robot like he used on Mitsuko to take her down, only he leaves it in the case and tosses an empty case so that Awatsuki is forced to chase the robot dog carrying it. Wannai uses her water abilities and does well, but Baba thinks he has her, not realizing she’s been hiding water. Awatsuki returns to assist since she caught the robot dog and defeated it. Baba is forced to bring a big praying mantis robot into play, but Mikoto arrives, having learned what happened from Saten, putting an end to Baba’s hopes of a victory.

Thoughts/Review:

Well now, well now. What a great volume this turned out to be.

I loved that Wannai and Awatsuki got to be the stars for a while in this volume. They’ve just been small, side-characters who seem fairly reserved and even timid (they call Mikoto “Misaka-sama”). They became Mitsuko’s best friends.  As such, it was so awesome to see them get angry and let loose when they saw what Baba had done to Mitsuko. Despite not being high level espers, nor combat trained espers, they do quite well. Wannai’s “Hydro Hand” ability to control water and Awatsuki’s “Float Dial” ability to control buoyancy (with some telekinetic control) go well together. But even split apart, the two do well. No wonder they are students at Tokiwadai. ^_^  I love it when the B-team gets to do stuff like this.

I love how Mitsuko works with Mikoto here. For the next anime series, I hope they’ve “fixed” the issues created by the first anime series’ portrayal of Mitsuko. She’s someone Mikoto can trust and Mitsuko knows this, thus her warning to be wary of any information Mitsuko initially reports to her, lest it be disinformation from Misaki. It is a shame that Mitsuko didn’t get to unleash on Baba, but she’ll get her turn.

As to the bigger plot, Misaki and her Mental Out ability is something else. With her ability to control people, wipe memories, and plant false memories, I can’t help but wonder how Accelerator would defend against her unless he too has some sort of natural defense against her like Mikoto has.

Regardless, I’m not sure what Misaki is up to here. She’s got Misaka-10032 and she’s got Saten, Uiharu, and Kuroko so that they don’t see Mikoto as a friend, but just someone they are aware of.  While it seemed that Baba might have been working for her, he’s obviously working for someone else.  I get the feeling that since she can’t control Mikoto directly, she’s manipulating Mikoto into doing some sort of dirty work for her against whomever Baba is working for. Then, if Mikoto confronts Misaki directly, Misaki can protect herself by using Mikoto’s friends and Misaka-10032 as hostages.

Which reminds me, could Misaki have an interest in the Sisters project?  She is apparently having Misaka-10032 treated and cared for, but there may be more to it than whatever plans Misaki has for Mikoto.

Mikoto’s mother isn’t getting much air time in the manga. I suppose that’s because she was featured on Index side of the Daihasei Festival arc. Still, I hope we get to see other things about her mother that we didn’t get to see (or read) on the Index side.

On the Seven Seas side of things, we get the usual stuff — full Japanese honorifics and some of the extras from the original tankoubon. There’s a preview for Zero’s Familiar, which I did look at, but I’m not so sure about for certain reasons.

So, a good volume that allows side characters Wannai and Awatsuki to have a huge moment in the sun.


You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

11 Responses to “A Certain Scientific Railgun Vol. 08 Manga Review (Time for the B-Team to Shine!)”

  1. ghostbeetle says:

    “having learned what happened from Satan…” LOL!
    I did not know Mikoto had a direct line to the Dark Prince the Beast Of The Apocalypse, the Lightbringer himself!

  2. Anonymous says:

    Actually, all of the Level 5s from 1-3 should be able to defend against Misaki’s mind control. Accelerator should easily be able to do so since Misaki’s powers seem to be vector based since Mikoto was able to block it. The Number 2 probably should be able to block it because of Dark Matter. I am not sure if pre-New Testament Kakine would be able to block it but New Testament Kakine (aka Hollow Kakine & Rhinoceros Beetle Kakine) should be able to block it since his body is made of Dark Matter. Mikoto should be able to for obvious reasons. Whether Mugino could block Misaki is debatable.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Oh, yeah…one more thing I didn’t mention in my previous comment: notice that when Misaki introduced herself to Touma, Touma never mentioned his name yet she knew. That one page on its own started the speculations that Touma and Misaki once knew each other prior to Touma’s memory loss. Ever since then, it’s been made pretty obvious (in the Index novels which were released since that chapter was released in Japan) that they have some sort of past together but we don’t exactly know the nature of that relationship (although it’s heavily implied that Misaki fell in love with him).

    • AstroNerdBoy says:

      I did notice Misaki knew Touma’s name, but I just assumed she’d done her homework on those in Mikoto’s “clique” (for lack of a better term). Interesting to hear this bit of speculation on her possible past with Touma. Thanks. ^_^

    • Anonymous says:

      The thing is that the reason people began to speculate was because of the drastic change in expression had after Touma showed up and asked who Misaki was. You never see her eyes, but the shape of her mouth can tell you that it was either shock or disappointment, which are expressions which aren’t exactly something you would see Misaki have when meeting someone for the first time. It was confirmed in the most recent Index novel that they did have some sort of relationship prior to his memory loss but nothing beyond that. Although, the nature of their relationship became a bit more obvious in the most recent Railgun chapter in Japan but I won’t say anything further to detract from your enjoyment.

      By the way, I would honestly recommend reading all of the novels (Index+ Index Side Story + Railgun Side Story) just because the franchise in general makes a lot more sense when you see the bigger picture. If you only follow just the Railgun manga, Railgun anime, and Index anime, you won’t see the whole big picture. For example, that girl that Saten thought she knew in the previous volume is explained in both a Railgun Side Story and an Index Volume that takes place shortly after Season II of Index. Since the Index novels likely will not get licensed, I don’t see any harm in reading them.

    • AstroNerdBoy says:

      Yeah, I do need to read all that. ^_^; It would be easier if I had a pad so I could read in bed.

    • AstroNerdBoy says:

      Oh, and thanks for the info. ^_^

  4. […] reading volume 8, I had been figuring that Misaki was probably the antagonist, but I wasn’t completely sure […]

  5. Mathias Rosier says:

    Accelerator has the Vector Control so yeah he has this sort of protection

Leave a Reply to ghostbeetle Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Powered by WordPress